Navalny found secret yachts, mansions and wineries from Medvedev. FBK published an investigation into the luxury real estate of Prime Minister Dmitry Medvedev

Navalny found secret yachts, mansions and wineries from Medvedev. FBK published an investigation into the luxury real estate of Prime Minister Dmitry Medvedev

“He’s not Dimon for you,” dedicated to Prime Minister Dmitry Medvedev. The 13 chapters of the publication talk about the prime minister’s luxury real estate in Russia and abroad.

Thus, according to the Foundation, Medvedev received a house and 4.3 hectares of land in the village of Znamenskoye near the Rublevo-Uspenskoye Highway as a gift from billionaire Alisher Usmanov. FBK estimated the cost of the site and construction at approximately 5 billion rubles.

Formally, the property is registered with the Fund for Support of Socially Significant State Projects, the supervisory board of which is headed by Medvedev’s classmate Ilya Eliseev. “This foundation has nothing to do with charity and does not carry out noticeable activities. The fund is managed by the same people as the Dar and Gradislava foundations, which own Medvedev’s residence in Ples and other personal properties of the prime minister,” the investigation says .

In addition, according to FBK, Medvedev has an estate with an area of ​​about 240,000 square meters in the village of Mansurovo, Kursk region. The residence is registered as the property of the Mansurovo agricultural complex. This agricultural complex and other agricultural enterprises in the Kursk region are managed by Eliseev, as well as the Prime Minister’s cousin Andrei Medvedev.

FBK found Medvedev’s winter residence in Krasnaya Polyana. “On four hectares of reserved land there are several buildings, including a residence with an area of ​​4 thousand square meters. As in the story with Medvedev’s Plyos dacha, during the Olympic construction stage the land lease was issued to the Dar Foundation. At the end of 2014, the property was donated the unknown Winter Olympic Sports Support Fund,” the investigation says. The fund's supervisory board is headed by Eliseev.

In addition, as stated in the FBK publication, Medvedev owns the Milovka estate in Ples, vineyards in the Anapa region, a plot near the village of Maslovo on Rublevo-Uspenskoye Highway, as well as two plots by the sea in the Krasnodar Territory and a mansion in St. Petersburg. An offshore company associated with Medvedev owns two yachts, the material says.

The Fund claims that all of the listed property “was acquired with bribes from oligarchs and loans from state banks.” “A dacha in Ples, an estate on Rublevka donated by Usmanov, a secret mountain dacha in Psekhako, lands in Utrish, Olginka and the village of Maslovo near Moscow, Anapa vineyards, the count’s palace converted into apartments with car elevators, agribusiness and yachts - all this is serviced from a single center," the report says.

“Financing is also centralized. Donations, contributions, loans are distributed by the management companies of the Dar fund, the money is taken offshore to be spent on yachts and Italian vineyards. Dozens of legal entities, unrelated at first glance, are actually united by common employees and addresses , real estate often turns out to be registered in the names of the same people, but the only element that unites all this into the system is Dmitry Anatolyevich Medvedev,” FBK claims.

In September, the Alexei Navalny Foundation already published an investigation about Medvedev’s dacha in Ples . Then the prime minister's press secretary, Natalya Timakova, said that this facility "is not the property of Dmitry Anatolyevich Medvedev and is not used by him and members of his family on another legal basis."


A trifle. Just a funny little thing like sneakers or a shirt with a bright pattern can betray even the most sophisticated corrupt official and become the starting point for exposing him. This happened in our history. Prime Minister Dmitry Medvedev created for himself the image of an official whom no one takes seriously. His most odious statements evoke ridicule in society rather than anger. They treat him with leniency, because at least he doesn’t seem like an outright villain.

Even after FBK declassified his secret dacha in Plyos - one of the most expensive properties we have ever filmed - the opinion about him did not fundamentally change. Everyone still considers him an eccentric who was out of place, weak-willed, but essentially a good person, a lover of funny gadgets, not palaces. Today we will tell you how wrong everyone was. Dmitry Anatolyevich Medvedev is not at all a funny eccentric who should be laughed at. He is the creator and head of a huge, multi-level corruption scheme. The head of the ruling United Russia party owns real estate throughout the country, he owns huge tracts of land in the most elite areas, he manages yachts, apartments in old mansions, agricultural complexes and wineries in Russia and abroad.

All this property was acquired with bribes from oligarchs and loans from state banks. The Prime Minister and his trusted people created a criminal scheme based not on offshore companies, as is often the case, but on non-profit foundations. This is a very clever solution. The real owner of the assets is almost impossible to trace because, being registered in charitable foundations, they, in fact, do not belong to anyone. Medvedev’s property is managed by his friends, classmates and proxies. The structure of this criminal scheme is so complex that it took us several months to describe it, and it is unknown how we would have proven Medvedev’s involvement in it, but here we were lucky. The former president, current prime minister and owner of colossal corruption assets was given... ordinary sneakers.

The “Dar” Foundation, stated in the publication, is headed by Medvedev’s classmate and friend Ilya Eliseev. Navalny calls him one of the closest people to the head of government. Thus, Eliseev manages the Mansurovo agricultural complex and other agricultural enterprises in the Kursk region, as follows from the Unified State Register of Legal Entities. In the same area, the Navalny Foundation notes, the head of government has a “family estate, which he regularly visits”: “A chapel was built on the site of a house that once belonged to Medvedev’s grandfather. The estate and tens of thousands of square meters of agricultural land are the property of Mansurovo.

Among the members of the board of directors of Mansurovo is Andrei Medvedev, whom FBK calls the prime minister’s cousin. He is also the owner of a small share in the Seim-Agro company. The main founder of Seim-Agro is the Kurskpromteplitsa company, which belongs to the Sotsgosproekt foundation, associated with Medvedev.

Andrei Medvedev refused to confirm to RBC his family connection with the Russian prime minister. “This is a purely personal question, I do not consider it necessary to answer it,” he said. He also noted that “he received neither help nor interference from the said person [Dmitry Medvedev].” “If this were really the case, as a true patriot of our state, I would be truly saddened. Such accusations have no basis. This is fiction and folklore,” Medvedev is sure.

Vineyard in Tuscany

A subsidiary of the Dar Foundation has registered a house on Rublyovka and 20 hectares of land, which previously belonged to the presidential administration and were sold, according to FBK, “200 times cheaper than the market value.” FBK refers to court materials and information from Rosreestr.

Eliseev’s student Philip Polyansky and former director of Dar heads the company Certum-Invest, as indicated in the extract from the Unified State Register of Legal Entities. The company acquired a historic mansion in St. Petersburg, then transferred it to Dar, after which the building was rebuilt into an elite building of 29 apartments.

Eliseev owns the Cyprus offshore company Furcina, to which two sea yachts are registered, according to extracts from the Cyprus register of legal entities. FBK estimated their cost at $16 million. “We see them moored near the Milovka estate in Ples, which is Medvedev’s residence. Both yachts are named “Photinia”, which is the church equivalent of the name Svetlana. This is the name of Dmitry Medvedev’s wife,” the authors of the investigation note.

A winery in Italian Tuscany is registered with the same offshore company, as indicated in the legal entity’s annual report. “After the purchase, Sergei Stupnitsky became the manager of the winery, a man who had previously worked as the director of another winery associated with the Prime Minister, the Anapa Rocky Coast,” FBK emphasizes. A representative of Fattoria della Aiola, through which Furcina controls wine production, in a comment to RNS denied the winery’s connection with Medvedev.

The Sotsgosproekt fund, associated with Medvedev, according to SPARK-Interfax, owns a stake in the Skalisty Bereg company. She, in turn, owns vineyards in Anapa. One of the directors of the Rocky Coast subsequently became the director of the Gradislava Foundation. Medvedev’s Plyos estate is “registered” to this fund, the authors of the investigation write.

In addition to Eliseev, FBK names Vladimir Dyachenko as a key figure in the prime minister’s entourage. “This person is involved in the daily management of the Rublyovsky estate in Znamensky, received as a gift from Alisher Usmanov,” Navalny’s foundation points out.

Donations and loans

Navalny writes, citing financial statements, that funds associated with Medvedev have several sources of funding. Firstly, as FBK notes, “NOVATEK shareholders Leonid Mikhelson and Leonid Simanovsky contributed 33 billion rubles to the authorized capital of the Dar fund.” Secondly, the management company of the Dar fund received loans from Gazprombank in the amount of 11 billion rubles, as follows from the financial institution’s reporting. “Such support from Gazprombank can be explained very simply. Medvedev’s main confidant, Ilya Eliseev, is the deputy chairman of the board of this bank,” Navalny points out. “Together with the money received from the oligarchs, the volume of funds circulating between Medvedev’s funds and companies is almost 70 billion rubles.”

The Meritage company manages all the property of the Prime Minister. FBK makes this conclusion, for example, on the basis that the company selects personnel for all other legal entities associated with the head of government.

“Although Eliseev is a classmate of Medvedev, he is still a fairly independent figure. That is, what belongs to Eliseev cannot also belong to Medvedev. For the role of majordomo - manager of Medvedev’s property, Eliseev’s figure is too big,” -

He's not Dimon for you

It was a huge job, and at first we were not at all sure that it could be done on our own. But we did. We found and filmed (!!!) all the residences in Russia and abroad, found the damn elusive yachts and scrupulously used geotags, photos from Instagram and archival records to establish where and who sailed on them. They were hiding from the FSO guarding the facilities. We spent hundreds of man-hours analyzing social networks and looking for the necessary photos. They shoveled through offshore documentation. We looked at domain names. We literally looked at every photo of the main character for a year to find the right sneakers and shirts (that’s where it all started). We went to Tuscany to photograph vineyards, and to the Kursk region to photograph cows.

Damn, we even bought the rights to the song by the group “Combination” to make this movie more fun for you to watch.

Dmitry Anatolyevich Medvedev is not at all the harmless and comic character he seems to be. Don't let it deceive you sleeping in meetings , badminton, or passion for gadgets.

This is a very cunning and greedy person, clearly slightly obsessed with residences and luxury real estate and, for the sake of owning them, created one of the largest corruption schemes in the country. And, we must give him his due, one of the most sophisticated.

We found, described and documented the existence of a network of charitable and non-profit foundations organized by Medvedev's proxies and relatives. The word “charitable” should not confuse: the only recipients of “help” here are Medvedev and his family.

They use the funds to receive “donations” (read: bribes) from oligarchs and state-controlled banks and spend the funds on the purchase of palaces, yachts and vineyards in Russia and abroad.

And yes - it's very clever. Who owns, for example, Medvedev’s secret dacha in Plyos, about which we did a lot of research? Formally, no one. The charitable organization is the Gradislav Foundation, which means there are not even individuals who are the ultimate owners, because the property of a non-profit organization ultimately belongs only to it, and not even to its founders.

In fact, everyone understands: the dacha belongs to Medvedev. She is protected by the FSO. The service department is located there. There is even an official no-fly zone above the Plyos dacha.

That is, the corruption scheme is based on the creation of a charitable organization with a reliable person (classmate, relative) at the head. After which you can safely pump the organization with money and buy palaces-yachts with it, without fear that someone will poke it in your face with a piece of paper where your name is in the “owner” column.

There’s just one problem: there can’t be too many reliable people. If there are a small number of individuals involved in the organization, financing and management of a bunch of charitable foundations, the main feature of which is the ownership of the property of Prime Minister Medvedev, then everything becomes clear: this is corruption.

Starting with these fun colored sneakers,

we have established and documented the entire corruption empire of Dmitry Medvedev, the funds that make up it, and his closest confidants.

This
— bribes from oligarchs Usmanov and Mikhelson;
- money from Gazprombank, which has been seen many times before to act as a “wallet” to cover the expenses of high-ranking officials (see the “Vinokur case” and “Sechin’s wife’s salary case”);
— transfers from other companies (for example, a subsidiary of Bashneft).

This money was used to build, purchase and maintain:

Medvedev’s family estate and agricultural complex in Mansurovo:

Mansurovo

Mountain residence "Psekhako" in Sochi:

Vineyards in Anapa and Tuscany:

Milovka, which we showed earlier:

And much more, which we talk about in our investigation. In its video version. And in its detailed text version with all the documents.

Here I will briefly talk about only one episode, which is enough to send both Medvedev and Usmanov to the dock.

Do you know how this object worth 5 billion ended up in Medvedev’s possession?

Alisher Burkhanovich Usmanov, one of the richest oligarchs in Russia with a fortune of $12.5 billion, simply donates both land and a mansion to Medvedev’s foundation.

What should I call it? That's right: a bribe.

That's what we call it in our crime report. And in general, this entire investigation of ours, both as a whole and broken down into episodes, will be turned into statements of crimes.

Yes, we understand that now the authorities will do everything to prevent any steps that law enforcement agencies are obliged to take. That is, what happened with Chaika will be repeated. But, as they say, you have to live long in Russia. Sooner or later we will achieve our goal and see all the characters in the dock. And sitting next to them will be those who will block the investigation now.

However, even this is not the main thing now. You and I understand very well that the Kremlin will devote its main efforts not to working with “law enforcement officers” (otherwise Chaika and Bastrykin themselves don’t understand what to do), but to stop the spread of information about the investigation .

They have 100% control over their servants in uniform, but public opinion and the heads of citizens are not so easy to control. Yes, of course, zombie guy, that’s all, but nevertheless, with our joint efforts we can easily make a hole in the picture of the world of the average citizen of the Russian Federation.

Let's make efforts to achieve this together. Moreover, it has such an attractive and understandable format, with aerial filming. We must ensure that all those 20 million people below the poverty line look at Medvedev’s apartments with elevators for cars and angels for fireplaces.

Don't fall into the trap Why should I spread this link, everyone has already seen it" Not all. It is your link, your comment that is missing. It’s not enough to just throw it on Facebook today. Today. And then tomorrow. And just to be sure, in two days.

A couple of emails. SMS to your beloved grandmother. A letter to a classmate with the subject " look at Medvedev's castle in Italy».

By the way, I want to say that in social networks for older people, visual content of this kind works even better. Video clip about Medvedev's Milovka It has 4.2 million views on YouTube, and 7 million on Odnoklassniki. This is despite the fact that we ourselves did not post it on Odnoklassniki - people themselves stole it from their accounts.

If you don’t want to send it to your grandmother, but want to send it to a foreign friend, no problem - here’s a description of the investigation in English.

A separate appeal to journalists:

First of all, how much can you be afraid? You can't spend your whole life publishing what not scary.

Secondly, this is your traffic, your clicks, your circulation. People read nothing better than corruption investigations with such texture.

Thirdly, this is your chance to make your profession interesting and rewarding. Each episode of this investigation can and should be supplemented with its own story. Comment from an interested person. Just going to the scene of the event. We have revealed only the most basic things. Who knows, maybe you will get attached to something (like we do to sneakers) and find something that will make you the main journalist in the country. Your name will be mentioned in journalism departments when talking about how to do investigations.

In general, dear everyone, help. Our work has no meaning unless millions know about it. This is our joint project with you, and your contribution is no less important.

Well, don’t forget that I need your signatures in support of the nomination. The Anti-Corruption Foundation exists and does such investigations only thanks to. Support us if you think we are doing something useful.

They unite and protect each other to build palaces for themselves, and let us act together to regain our country.

Dmitry Medvedev's press secretary Natalya Timakova said that the Anti-Corruption Foundation's investigation into the prime minister's "secret empire" was underway. It has a “clearly expressed election character. According to her, it is “pointless” to comment on these accusations, Interfax reports.

Having connected various facts together, we eventually came to a whole grandiose corruption empire, where there are vineyards in Anapa, vineyards in Tuscany, a mountain residence, two estates on Rublyovka... It is difficult to describe this investigation in a few words, it is very large, and it simply shows that people spent 70 billion rubles on entertainment. Georgy Alburov

The director of the Anti-Corruption Foundation (FBK) of Alexei Navalny, Roman Rubanov, sent on Thursday to the Investigative Committee of Russia (ICR) a statement to initiate a criminal case against Prime Minister Dmitry Medvedev and businessman Alisher Usmanov under Art. 290 of the Criminal Code (taking a bribe) and Art. 291 of the Criminal Code (giving a bribe). Vedomosti

Mansions, vineyards, yachts: Dmitry Medvedev broke the law?

The Anti-Corruption Foundation has published a large-scale investigation about Prime Minister Dmitry Medvedev. It follows from the material that people and charitable foundations associated with Medvedev own several luxury residences in Russia and abroad, agricultural land and two yachts. Alexei Navalny calls Medvedev’s actions a criminal offense; in an interview with Dozhd, he said that the prime minister “can be sent to the dock even tomorrow.” Deputy General Director of Transparency International - Russia Ilya Shumanov explained to Meduza that from the point of view of the letter of the law, it is difficult to blame Medvedev for anything.

Legal argumentation is the weakest point of the new Anti-Corruption Foundation investigation. I don’t see anything illegal in what Mr. Medvedev did. The fact is that due to gaps in Russian legislation, it turns out that all the assets listed in the investigation are registered in accordance with the law. That is, if you look precisely from the point of view of the letter of the law, everything is completely legal.

The assets discussed in the investigation belong to non-profit charitable organizations. For example, the residence donated by [businessman] Alisher Usmanov is his contribution to the NGO. Such organizations formally do not have owners and do not involve making a profit or withdrawing assets. These assets are managed by a hired manager, and it is difficult to determine who the real owner is. I will not evaluate the arguments related to sneakers and hacked emails, because they are outside the legal field and legal expertise.

Dmitry Medvedev himself is not mentioned in the documentation of the charitable organizations involved in the investigation. It mentions people close to the prime minister and, in particular, [his classmate] Ilya Eliseev. One could say that he is the nominal owner of these non-profit funds, but [in fact] he is quite a self-sufficient figure. Since 2005, Eliseev has held the position of deputy chairman of Gazprombank and is on the board of directors of Gazprom-Media, so he could have acquired all these assets himself and used them. It turns out that Medvedev may not be involved in all this.

The form of a non-profit organization is a corruption-prone hole in the Russian legal field. In this case, a legal scheme provides the opportunity for illegal enrichment and avoids liability. I think, when commenting on the investigation, Medvedev and Eliseev will point specifically to the legal side, and the ethical side will be behind the scenes.

FBK conducted a good, logical investigation. If the prime minister uses the property of the deputy chairman of the board of Gazprombank, who studied with him in the same course, this creates a situation of conflict of interest. This is a sign of a corruption offense for which there should be some kind of responsibility. But the investigation's findings do not mention a conflict of interest.

In a European country, this whole situation would be a reason for the resignation of the prime minister and cabinet, but in Russia this is unlikely.

“We found 80 percent of the schemes in 20 percent of the time spent”Interview with Georgy Alburov, one of the authors of the investigation into the property of Dmitry Medvedev

Georgy Alburov and quadcopter. Photo: Evgeny Feldman for FBK

- Did this investigation really start with a pair of sneakers seen on Dmitry Medvedev?

Of course, it started with many things at the same time, but a pair of sneakers is such a very important expressive part, it really helped us a lot. It turned out that the entire corruption scheme can be traced back to the purchase of this pair. These sneakers were ordered for one of the people closest to Prime Minister Medvedev. We began to look at what else there was behind this man - and immediately went out to vineyards, houses, including an estate in the old village of Mansurovo, where Medvedev’s ancestors lived. Yes, the sneakers helped us a lot.

Was the whole scheme drawn up quickly or was it difficult to find people close to the prime minister and identify them?

We found 80 percent of the schemes in 20 percent of the time spent. With the rest it was more difficult - we went from one legal entity to another, we did not see any connection. Then people from one of our schemes suddenly found themselves connected to companies from a completely different part of the scheme. It began to become more complicated and confusing, but with each new discovery it was clear: all these people we are talking about are directly related to Dmitry Medvedev. There were no particular difficulties with identification: lists of Medvedev’s classmates are publicly available and open. It was more difficult to identify the students, but we identified them by year of graduation.

There was still a question about one person; we could not verify him. Someone Vitaly Golovachev. He was in the insurance business in the late 1990s - he litigated on behalf of insurance companies, then disappeared for ten years and suddenly turned up as a top manager at Gazprombank, at the Meritage company, at the Dar charity foundation ( all organizations appear in the FBK investigation - approx. "Jellyfish"). Unfortunately, it was not possible to communicate with him.

- From your point of view, all these people were very secretive about their activities?

Most likely, Medvedev was confident that he would transfer all the property to some non-profit foundations that do not pay taxes. He will appoint his classmates there, or their students, in cases where classmates are too pale, and this scheme will work. Yes, it is quite reliable in terms of management: all these people are close to Medvedev, super trusted persons. But the problem is that the number of such people is very limited. Such a scheme could have been identified a long time ago.

- How many people were involved in the investigation?

Six months ago we started... At first there were two people, towards the end four people were involved in the investigation, and another six were involved in the website, video, graphics, music and other things. I will say this: the amount of effort we spent on making all this look good, readable and remembered is even greater than the amount of effort [spent] on collecting facts.

- Tell us about the quadcopter; filming from it is a separate important part of the investigation.

The quadcopter is our faithful fighter, he has been with us since last year and helps us a lot. This is a basic model and can be purchased at any hardware store. It shoots well: we learned how to work with it and smooth out some technical difficulties. If you estimate roughly, 20 million people have seen the video that was made with its help. This is our indispensable tool and practically a team member.

-Are the rights to the songs of the group “Combination” the same beautiful detail as with the sneakers? Why do you need them?

Not so simple! At some point we realized that we were using the song too many times. And I wouldn’t want YouTube to ban us for copyright infringement. So we went to the owners of these songs and formalized the purchase of the rights to use them. The copyright holders, interestingly, were very surprised; no one had ever bought the rights to songs from them in their lives; they didn’t even have a template agreement. It cost quite a bit of money, about 10 thousand rubles per song. It's worth it so we don't get banned.

With your investigation, you have convincingly proven that Dmitry Medvedev’s inner circle lives well. Do you think you have convincingly managed to prove that all these people were buying everything they could in the interests of the Prime Minister?

Yes, anyone can come to us and ask: what does Medvedev have to do with it? His classmates, relatives and friends are here. But we have collected enough facts for ourselves and everyone else to answer this question. Look: how many people are there in the world to whom [businessman] Alisher Usmanov gives estates, and even a real palace on Rublyovka? Not so much. Medvedev visited all these facilities and used them. We convincingly prove this.

In Psekhako, we used a drone to photograph the chimneys of a country house in the mountains and compared them with those that Medvedev posts on his Instagram. These are the same pipes. Regarding the yacht, we found the geolocation of this yacht over the past two years. She went to Plyos four times, where Medvedev has a residence, and twice to the Scarlet Sails festival in St. Petersburg. This is a holiday for graduates, a beautiful event, fireworks. Shipping is closed there at this moment. The only yacht for which an exception was made is the yacht “Photinia”, with which Medvedev took his photographs and also posted them. All this is ironclad evidence.

Part of the property you are talking about is registered in charitable foundations. Have you seen their reports? Who are they helping at all?

This is an interesting question in the sense that we don't know - they don't publish their reports. They do not submit reports to the Ministry of Justice, as required by law. Our fund is renting, but they are not. This is a direct violation of the law. They can be found on the tax office website, but it is difficult to draw correct conclusions from the information there. For example, they issue a cadastral valuation for real estate, and the estate on Rublyovka, with a market value of two billion rubles, is valued much lower.

- How do you like the first one?reactionfor investigation?

I read the reaction of [Prime Minister Natalya] Timakova’s press secretary... You know, all my life I was sure that she was a rather reserved person from whom you couldn’t hear words like “I will not comment on the words of this opposition criminal-politician.” What kind of state did she have to be brought to in order for her to utter such words? But our investigation did it - very nice. I hope there will be more substantive comments, including from law enforcement agencies.

May I live like this, Dimon!

I strongly advise you to watch the film of the Anti-Corruption Foundation about Medvedev’s dachas, vineyards, estates and yachts. And watch it not even to find out what specific estates, apartments and mountain ranges belong to Dmitry Anatolyevich, what they look like and where they are located. And watch in order to experience this feeling. This feeling will not necessarily be indignation, disgust or disgust. Although what you will see is criminal and shameful for the country. No! I'm talking about something else.

Look at all this splendor, and then listen to yourself. And inside, if not everyone, then very many, this insidious voice will sound: “Damn! Yes, I wish I could live like this!” Really, looking at the swimming pools and the car elevator and the marble staircase in the apartment like a palace, didn’t you want to live like that for at least a couple of days? And a mansion in St. Petersburg, and a 17th century villa in Italy, and a family estate in Kursk, and just an estate in Plyos! We are not holy ascetics or altruists. But for the most part we work a lot for little money. And here, on the screen, is a life that we cannot even dream of. But someone lives such a life, and we know this person, and he is one of those who controls us!

In the end, Navalny says words that are completely obvious, but no less correct: there, at the heights of power, all this is not a secret - because at the heights of power they all live one way or something like this, in accordance with the positions they occupy and the degree of their arrogance. And I will be surprised if there is at least someone among them who lives differently. And this is precisely why they strive for power. That is why power is the main asset in Russia. Neither your talents, nor your brains, nor your resourcefulness or ingenuity - nothing matters here. Only position and authority matter.

In Russia there is no point in becoming Elon Musk, because people who change the world are not needed here. We need people here who will leave everything as before. Russia does not need people who earn money thanks to incredible technologies or modern production. Because it is troublesome and time-consuming, and the risk is high. You can make money much easier and much faster by being a prosecutor, judge, minister or even prime minister, as it turns out. More precisely, not to earn, but to receive.

In developed countries, money is important because it gives power. In Russia, on the contrary, the authorities give money. And the authorities can take away the money. Ask Khodorkovsky, who was the richest man in the country and set out to change something in politics - what happened to him and did he like it? That is why the current oligarchs do not make the same mistakes and will donate billions to all sorts of fake funds and give away estates in order to remain oligarchs, and not sew mittens in prison.

Navalny made a powerful film, but I doubt that this film will blow up society. And not only because a minority of the population will still know about it. And also because millions of our fellow citizens themselves would like to live like this, and to live like this, not thanks to their talents and enterprise, but in order to have power, and to have everything that this power can give in our country. And she can give anything - if only she had imagination and arrogance.

The Kremlin responded to the FBK investigation into Medvedev’s real estate within 24 hours

The Kremlin is not “in detail” familiar with the Anti-Corruption Foundation’s investigation into Prime Minister Dmitry Medvedev’s real estate. The investigation was published the day before, March 2. The Cabinet of Ministers stated that it is of an election nature.
Press Secretary of the Russian President Dmitry Peskov answered the question of whether the head of state Vladimir Putin is familiar with the investigation of Alexei Navalny’s Anti-Corruption Foundation about the “secret real estate” of Prime Minister Dmitry Medvedev, an RBC correspondent reports.

“We are not familiar with the details. We saw the media reports. These are not the first examples of the work of this famous convicted citizen. There is nothing to add to what was said by the press secretary of the Prime Minister,” he said.

The day before, commenting on the investigation, the press secretary of the head of the Cabinet of Ministers, Natalya Timakova, said that the material was of a clearly pre-election nature. “Navalny’s material is clearly pre-election in nature, as he himself says at the end of the video. It makes no sense to comment on the propaganda attacks of an oppositional and convicted character who said that he is already waging some kind of election campaign and is fighting the authorities,” she noted.

The FBK investigation was published the day before, on March 2. It says that Medvedev owns “huge tracts of land in the most elite areas, manages yachts, apartments in old mansions, agricultural complexes and wineries in Russia and abroad.”

The authors of the investigation draw their conclusions based on data from Rosreestr, extracts from various registers of legal entities, as well as publications in the media and posts on social networks. At the same time, the FBK points out that the real owner of the assets “is almost impossible to track, since, being registered with charitable foundations, they do not belong to anyone.”

Such objects, according to FBK, are, in particular, real estate in the village of Znamenskoye near Rublevo-Uspenskoye Highway, an estate in the Kursk region, a winery in Italian Tuscany and a number of others. Medvedev’s property is managed by his friends, classmates and confidants, the investigation states.

The effect of an unexploded bomb: how the media did not notice Navalny’s investigation into Medvedev

FBK head Alexei Navalny called the investigation into the “secret empire of Dmitry Medvedev” published by the Anti-Corruption Foundation the foundation’s most ambitious project. Russian media reacted differently to the investigation; many ignored the FBK publication. Not only federal television channels, but also the media, which previously paid more attention to Navalny’s publications, decided not to write or talk about the investigation.

TV and Radio

Federal TV channels “Pervy”, “Russia 1” and NTV never mentioned Navalny’s investigation on their broadcast, it follows from the data of “Medialogy”, prepared at the request of Dozhd. Among cable TV channels, RBC paid attention to the investigation (17 materials during the day). From information radio stations, the publication was discussed by “Echo-Moscow” and “Business FM” - 33 and 4 materials, respectively. Kommersant FM and Vesti FM did not talk about the investigation.

Newspapers

Of the newspapers published on Friday, only two publications wrote about Navalny’s investigation: Vedomosti and Novaya Gazeta. The newspapers Kommersant, Izvestia, AiF, RBC, Moskovsky Komsomolets, Komsomolskaya Pravda and Nezavisimaya Gazeta wrote nothing about the oppositionist’s publication.

In Vedomosti, the FBK publication was devoted to the column “New Feedings” by Maria Zheleznova and Nikolai Epple in the opinion section, a material retelling the essence of the investigation “Premiere Show” on the second page, as well as Maxim Trudolyubov’s column “Inverted Tradition.”

Novaya Gazeta published the commentary “Reception against the successor.” It called the investigation “weighty and uncompromising,” seeing in the FBK publication the beginning of Navalny’s election campaign. “Navalny’s investigation highlights a non-obvious fact: Dmitry Anatolyevich is really the second person in the state<…>To be honest, I don’t know who else in our country is allowed to have such a resource - financial and political,” writes Alexey Polukhin, editor-in-chief of Novaya Gazeta.

Internet media

According to the Yandex-news service, the first news about the investigation appeared in online media at 13.15. Among the first to write about him were Mediazona, Republic, Echo of Moscow, RBC, Tsargrad (as well as Meduza, which is not indexed in the service). On the Kommersant website (owned by businessman Alisher Usmanov, whom Navalny mentions in the investigation), at 15:48 a news item was published under the heading “The Anti-Corruption Foundation has published another investigation.” Forbes published an article about “the fate of the site from Alexei Navalny’s investigation.” Life only posted a comment from Medvedev’s press secretary Natalya Timakova.

The websites of three major news agencies responded to the investigation after Timakova's comment at 2:40 p.m. At the same time, RIA Novosti did not retell the essence of the investigation in its report. “Earlier, Navalny posted a film with an “investigation” against Medvedev. Its authors stated that they spent more than six months collecting material,” RIA wrote.

Let's break through the information blockade and spread this information:
Thank you.
Read or add yours

The personal life and private property of Russian presidents is classified, but still some information appears in the media. We remembered which palaces and vineyards belong to government officials in Russia and compared them with some residences abroad.


Real estate of Vladimir Putin

Vladimir Putin's first service apartment is located in Moscow at the address: st. Akademika Zelensky, 6. The apartment number was not disclosed, but it is known that the area of ​​the four-room apartment was 157 m2. It is at this address that the president is still registered, although in fact he has not been there for a long time.

In the early 2000s, the president moved to the Odintsovo district of the Moscow region. Today, the residence in Novo-Ogarevo is considered the main place of residence of Vladimir Putin. The residence is surrounded by a six-meter fence, the territory is seriously guarded. Photography is permitted only during official events.



The residence housed the president's stable, made in the German style, a swimming pool, a gym, a residential building, a house for official receptions, a guest house with a cinema hall, a temple, and a helipad. There are greenhouses and a poultry house on the territory. There are no tours inside. The residence will officially remain with Vladimir Putin and his family after he steps down as president.



Interestingly, in March 2016, Radio Liberty noted that Putin’s neighbors directly behind the three-meter fence of the state residence are about twenty families of elderly Russians living in a two-story building of the estate’s former stables, built in the 19th century. The building is in disrepair: instead of a floor, there are wooden boards laid directly on the ground without a foundation, smoked ceilings in tiny damp rooms, plaster and wallpaper peeling off damp walls. They were promised to resettle them back in the 1980s.

Other residences of Putin

There are rumors about other Putin residences. They say that there are more than 20 of them. For example, oppositionist Alexei Navalny once published the following comparative table:

But what is truly known is the following residences, which the president often visits.

Bocharov stream.

The dacha complex is located in a prestigious area of ​​Sochi and includes a two-story villa, a holiday home for the Prime Minister and guest dachas. On the territory of 40 hectares there is also a large orchard, a sports complex, swimming pools, a press center and much more. Here, presidents often meet with high-ranking guests. There are also rumors that a beach complex with swimming pools and a spa area will be built next to the residence.

Long Beards (Valdai, Lake Dinner).

The residence is located in the Novgorod region near the city of Valdai. The residence is located on an area of ​​930 hectares - it is used mainly in the summer. The territory has everything “necessary”: restaurants, a cinema hall, a helipad. Representatives of the business elite live next door.

Volzhsky Utes.

This small health resort (only 400 hectares) is located in the Samara region in an ecologically clean forest area. On its territory of 400 hectares there is another residence, which includes a two-story building, a park, a winter garden, a swimming pool, and a mud bath.

Mayendorff.

And this is a real castle! Meiendorf is located in the village of Barvikha. In it, Vladimir Putin sometimes receives heads of foreign states and holds mass meetings. Meinedorf became the government residence after a major restoration in the early 2000s. The area is not closed to visitors.

Residences of Dmitry Medvedev

The numerous estates of Dmitry Medvedev became known after an investigation by the Anti-Corruption Foundation. The film “He's Not Dimon” was watched 25 million times. All real estate is registered in companies and non-profit foundations of Medvedev’s classmates. They also feature vineyards in the Krasnodar region and Tuscany, as well as two more yachts named after Svetlana Medvedeva, the prime minister’s wife. What did they find on Medvedev?

Residence in Ples

80 hectares on the banks of the Volga are surrounded by a three-meter fence. The acres include a private marina, a ski slope, three helipads, several houses, a hotel and other buildings and park facilities, including a giant chess board and a duck house that has particularly angered Russians.

Houses on Rublyovka.

An estate with an area of ​​three thousand square meters, a guest house of 750 square meters, and a bathhouse are located on four hectares in the village of Znamenskoye on Rublevka. The approximate cost is estimated at 5 billion rubles. FBK employees even found a photo on Instagram of one of the builders with the caption “Medvedev’s residence.” The second, more modest house, is located in Maslovo.

Manor in the village of Mansurovo in the Kursk region.

In the village of Mansurovo there is the family nest of Dmitry Medvedev - this is the native village of the prime minister’s ancestors. His grandfather lived there, his father grew up there. In Mansurovo they built a house with an area of ​​about one and a half thousand square meters, a guest house, and two helipads. In the village, on the site of Medvedev’s grandfather’s house, a chapel was erected, where it is written “Constructed with the assistance and diligence of Dmitry Anatolyevich Medvedev on the site of his ancestral house.” The chapel was consecrated on Medvedev’s 45th birthday in 2010, when he was still president.

Residence in Sochi.

On the Psekhako ridge near Krasnaya Polyana there is another residence of the former president with an area of ​​4,000 square meters. According to FBK, it is worth 2.6 billion rubles. Dmitry Medvedev posted photos from this residence on his Instagram.

Vineyards in the Krasnodar region and Tuscany.

The area of ​​vineyards in Anapa is one hundred hectares. “The relief here is such that if you stand with your back to the sea, you can imagine yourself in Tuscany. Soft contours of the hills, on the slopes of which there are even rows of vineyards. Exceptionally beautiful!” - said sommelier Arthur Sargsyan, who visited there. The second vineyard is located in Tuscany. There is also a 17th-century villa with 30 rooms. The entire Italian plot of 100 hectares cost $10 million.

Mansion in St. Petersburg.

But that's not all - another residence of Dmitry Medvedev is located in St. Petersburg. The mansion of Count Kushelev-Bezborodko on the Kutuzov embankment was built in the 18th century. It was recently converted into a residential building with 29 apartments, one of which has a car lift. Some of the apartments are for sale. Six apartments, according to FBK, cost about a billion rubles.

FBK also found 2 yachts worth about 16 million dollars. Dmitry Medvedev denies involvement in all of the above objects, although the connections are quite obvious.

Where do the presidents of other countries live?

Kultaranta - residence of the President of Finland

This small castle is the summer residence of the President of Finland. It is located in Naantali on the island of Luonnonmaa. About 20 thousand visitors visit the residence every year. Currently there are 19 rooms in the castle. On the lower floor there are festive and living spaces, on the upper floor there are bedrooms and places for guests. Marble steps lead to the castle tower and from above there is a beautiful view of the park and Naantali. The original furnishings of the mansion were not preserved - most of it was sold at auction. Official events are often held here. The residence does not belong to the president of the country - after the end of his term, he does not have the right to reside in it.

Bellevue Palace is the official residence of the German Chancellor

This beautiful palace has been the official residence of the Federal President of Germany since 1994. In 2005, the interior of the palace was restored according to the original surviving sketches, so that now the salons and reception rooms look very beautiful. Helicopters carrying the president's guests land on the green lawn in front of the palace. A flag on the roof means the president is in the palace. When the flag is lowered, the president is away. The park is open to the public until dark, but the palace can only be visited by prior arrangement.

Residence of Uruguay President Jose Mujica

During José Mujica's presidency, the world marveled at his modest lifestyle. He could have lived in the official residence, but he preferred his farm to it. In front of his house, clothes are dried on lines, and for water you have to go to a well in the middle of a grassy yard. The house is guarded by only two policemen and a three-legged dog named Manuela. Jose donated all his salary to charity.

“They call me the poorest president, but I don’t feel poor. The poor are those who work only to live in luxury. They want more and more all the time. This is a question of freedom,” the President of Uruguay commented on his lifestyle.

The Judeo-American team of D. Medvedev - the kings of Russian pulp and so on, so on, so on

Through Sberbank, the Russian President’s team transfers public money to the United States, turning it into their private property along the way.

In 1992, the St. Petersburg company Finzell was formed, which soon established the company ZAO Ilim Pulp Enterprise (IPE) ( registration number AOL-1546, authorized capital in the amount of 1,000,000 rubles). Among the founders of Finzell CJSC, in addition to Zakhar Davidovich Smushkin and brothers Zingarevichs included a St. Petersburg lawyer Dmitry Medvedev, now known as the “President of the Russian Federation”. At the same time, at Finzell CJSC Medvedev owned 50%, and Ilim Pulp Enterprise - 20%. This important fact was indicated by the Accounts Chamber in 2000 in a special report dedicated to raider takeovers carried out by the Zingarevich brothers and the future President of the Russian Federation.
The estimated value of the Ilim holding had already reached $1.5 billion by 2005. Consequently, there is reason to believe that Dmitry Anatolyevich’s personal capital even before his presidency was approaching a billion dollars.

This property is disguised, since Medvedev has been a civil servant for more than 11 years and cannot formally deal with commercial issues. The magazine “Profile” describes the history of capital as follows: “ Medvedev's business partners were not particularly clean in their conduct of business. In the fall of 1999, realizing that the matter was steadily heading towards an unpleasant trial, Medvedev hastily left the ranks of the management of Ilim and resigned from the founders of the Finzell company. Just at the moment when the state began checking the legality of a number of Ilim’s privatization projects. As a result, it became clear, for example, that the privatization of one of the largest enterprises of the company, the Kotlas Pulp and Paper Mill, was illegal. But this no longer had anything to do with Medvedev*. And by that time he no longer lived in St. Petersburg... Already in November 1999... Medvedev was appointed to the post of deputy chief of staff of the government Dmitry Kozak. And in December he became deputy head of the Kremlin administration Alexandra Voloshina ».

Forbes in 2006 rated the company as 24th in the ranking of non-public corporations. In the same year, it was the Ilim Pipe team that lobbied for the adoption of the forest code, after which came into force in 2007, Russian forests burned in 2010.

Ilim enterprises produce 60% of Russian pulp and 25% of cardboard. In 2007, Ilima enterprises produced 1.6 million tons of commercial pulp, 755,700 tons of cardboard and 258,800 tons of paper. The volume of own timber harvesting during this period amounted to 7.1 million cubic meters. m. The total number of personnel is over 20 thousand people. The group's turnover in 2007 amounted to 19 billion rubles, net profit - 3 billion rubles.(according to RAS, taking into account the reorganization of the company from July 1, 2007). Revenue in 2007 according to IFRS - $1.805 billion.

At the end of October 2006, it was announced that an agreement had been signed that 50% of Swiss-registered Ilim Holding, which owned more than 75% plus 1 share of Ilim Pulp's pulp and paper assets, would be sold to the American forestry company International Paper. Wherein Ilim Pulpa's timber processing assets were not included in the deal. Later, in 2007, Ilim's timber processing assets were spun off into a separate company. Ilim Timber Industry ».

Today, the official owners of Ilim are the Swiss company Ilim Holding, equal shares of which are owned, on the one hand, by the American International Paper and, on the other, Russian shareholders(including Chairman of the Board of Directors of the group Zakhar Davidovich Smushkin, members of the Board of Directors Boris And Michael Zingarevichi, Leonid Erukhimovich). The CEO is American Paul Herbert.




Zakhar Davidovich Leonid Erukhimovich Paul Herbert
Smushkin

It is difficult to say for sure which of them is specifically responsible for Dmitry Anatolyevich’s “small share.” Be that as it may, it was Mikhail Zingarevich, a member of the board of directors of the company, at a charity auction at the Christmas fair in St. Petersburg in 2010 bought for 51 million rubles a photograph of the Tobolsk Kremlin taken by Dmitry Medvedev .

Recently, Ilim, as “Medvedev’s personal wallet,” has been gradually withdrawing funds abroad. Moreover, the money is provided by the state-owned Sberbank, which finances the offshore investments of the Russian President in the economy of the United States and other developed countries. Recently, Ilim Timber closed a deal to purchase 100% of Tolleson Lumber Company, Vedomosti newspaper reported. Tolleson is one of the largest independent companies in the southern United States. A family-owned company founded in Georgia in 1919, Tolleson operates two sawmills in Perry and Preston, each producing 450,000 cubic meters. m of lumber per year. Tolleson sawmills are large for their region; the average capacity of local enterprises does not exceed 150,000 cubic meters. m

Such an asset became the first “timber” investment of the Medvedev-Zingarevich-Smushkin-Erukhimovich in America; the deal will increase Timber’s capacity by almost a quarter - to 3.9 million cubic meters. m of lumber per year. The parties did not disclose the purchase price, but Tolleson could cost $50-65 million. It is assumed that the sales markets for the new assets, in addition to the United States, will be China and Japan, which will soon need a large amount of construction materials to restore the destroyed infrastructure.
The situation when, through Sberbank and the Zingareviches, the Russian budget is transferred to a foreign business that is associated with Dmitry Medvedev is quite typical. As correspondents of the Fontanka.ru website wrote, in August 2010, with the support of Sberbank, the Zingarevichs formalized a deal to acquire two factories in Germany. The enterprises, for which the former owners managed to earn about 100 million euros, in their total capacity provide the new owners with about 2 million cubic meters of building materials per year. According to Ilim Timber, the factories mainly serve the markets of China and the Middle East.

In their native St. Petersburg, the Zingarevich brothers, in addition to their scandalous charity, are known for their development projects. Their interests include reconstruction of Vosstaniya Square and Konyushennaya Square. In addition, firms controlled by businessmen received a number of historical buildings from the city last year - on the Field of Mars, 1, letter A; Konyushennaya Square, 1, letter A; on Nevsky Prospekt, 7-9; embankment of the Moika River, 26, - for reconstruction for hotel accommodation.

From the same place grows Chief Executive Officer of the Skolkovo Innovation Center Michael (Yosef Michael ben Moshe) Moshiashvili, Managing Director of Ilim Pulp Enterprise Holding. 37 years old, native of Kutaisi. Georgian Jew, Jewish by religion. One of the leaders of the business club of the Russian Jewish Congress (REC). Former top manager of Deutsche Bank and Rosavia airlines, chairman of the board of directors of the investment bank United Financial Group (UFG), former employee of the World Bank, Vneshtorgbank of the Russian Federation and head of the treasury of the Yukos oil company. Speaks Hebrew, English, German.



(On the photo- Momiashvili on the right, wearing glasses, talks with a rabbi)


Well, this whole story, as well as the transfer of the capital of the largest timber processor to the jurisdiction of the United States and the specificity in the choice of partners, largely explain the close friendship of the Russian President with Washington and his diligence in eating hamburgers with the President Obama.


The main thing in this matter is not to choke.